Al-Jazeera: VS media ontwikkelen Goebbel's propaganda methoden

"If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it."

Dit was een van Joseph Goebbels motto's. In een Syrische krant die onder regerings controle staat wordt betoogd dat de VS nog een stap verder gaat dan Goebbels en daarmee nog effectiever en destructiever is. Het zou gaan om een verzoek van Cheney aan verschillende Amerikaanse kranten om de bevolking warm te maken voor een aanval op Iran.

"Lest anyone think that comparing the U.S. media, which is the most respected media in the world, to Goebbels's propaganda is a distortion of [reality] and grave injustice, here is a big, fresh headline [that appeared] in a American paper on Tuesday, September 4, 2007: 'Cheney Orders Media To Sell Attack On Iran: Fox News, Wall Street Journal instructed to launch PR blitz for upcoming military strike.'

Een krant die over Goebbels propaganda strategie uit de school klapte was geen lang bestaan meer beschoren, en de hoofdredacteur geen lang leven. Een kranteartikel dat Cheney van dergelijke praktijken beschuldigt, is wellicht het beste bewijs van de beperkte invloed van de Amerikaanse regering. Onlang stond er een artikel in de Britse Telegraph met de titel: "Bush setting America up for war with Iran". Anonieme bronnen vertellen over concrete plannen voor een aanval op Iran. Het artikel zegt:

In a chilling scenario of how war might come, a senior intelligence officer warned that public denunciation of Iranian meddling in Iraq - arming and training militants - would lead to cross border raids on Iranian training camps and bomb factories.

 

Dit suggereert dat alle kritiek op Iran vanwege haar rol in Irak is bedoeld om de geesten rijp te maken voor een invasie. Alles wat de VS zou doen om Irans bemoeienis in Irak tegen te gaan is zo bij voorbaat in discrediet gebracht (zou slechts dienen als aanleiding voor een oorlog tegen Iran...).
Hoe is een dergelijk artikel te rijmen met propaganda a la Goebbels?? Zou de weledelgeleerde Syrische schrijver van dit artikel werkelijk niet weten dat in de VS de regering gewoon geen controle heeft over wat de media schrijven?

 

Ratna

 

Zie ook Ami Isseroff's commentaar: A US attack on Iran?

_______________

Special Dispatch-Syria/U.S. and the Middle East
September 21, 2007
No. 1718

Senior Al-Jazeera Talk Show Host: U.S. Media Has Further Developed Goebbel's Propaganda Methods

To view this Special Dispatch in HTML, visit:
http://www.memri.org/bin/opener_latest.cgi?ID=SD171807.

In an article in the Syrian government daily Al-Thawra, the host of the Al-Jazeera TV talk show "Opposite Direction," Dr. Faisal Al-Qassim, stated that the U.S. media propaganda machine is employing the methods of Nazi propagandist Joseph Goebbels.

The following are the excerpts from the article(1):

"If Joseph Goebbels, Hitler's famous propaganda minister, were alive today, he would be demanding extensive compensation from the American media. Indeed, why not? These media are using his propaganda methods of premeditated and systematic lies, implementing them in toto without mentioning the inventor.

"In other words, we have here a clear case of the violation of copyright laws in respect to Goebbels' intellectual property. And since the Americans assign great importance to the intellectual property issue, they should acknowledge to the Nazi propaganda minister that they are copying his propaganda methods, and should pay him royalties. However, since the American media has extensively advanced Goebbels's propaganda methods, rendering them more destructive and effective – they have in fact registered a new patent, [which is why] they refrained from mentioning the source.

"Lest anyone think that comparing the U.S. media, which is the most respected media in the world, to Goebbels's propaganda is a distortion of [reality] and grave injustice, here is a big, fresh headline [that appeared] in a American paper on Tuesday, September 4, 2007: 'Cheney Orders Media To Sell Attack On Iran: Fox News, Wall Street Journal instructed to launch PR blitz for upcoming military strike.' This headline is not taken from an Arab newspaper or any [other] communications channel that wishes to denigrate the American media; it comes from an article written by prominent American journalist Paul Joseph Watson for the Prison Planet (a paper which gets most of its information from important U.S. papers and magazines such as the famous New Yorker).

"The American journalist quotes Brent Rubin, an expert on Afghanistan at the University of New York, who claims to have had long talks with the head of one of the institutes affiliated with the U.S. neo-cons – a senior official who told him that it was the vice president's office that issued instructions to launch an extensive and focused propaganda campaign [in order to] sell to the American people the idea of an attack on Iran one week after Labor Day(2) [According to the report,] to this end the Enterprise Institute will coordinate with the newspapers The Wall Street Journal and The Weekly Standard [sic],  the magazine Commentary, the Fox channel, and other papers, periodicals, and TV and radio channels. The vice president's office requested that the media step up its propaganda campaign and coordinate it carefully so as to persuade the Americans to accept the impending attack on Iran, whether it is just or not.

"Attention! The U.S. media – and everyone's already got a headache from all the talk about their 'reliability', 'independence' and 'freedom' – is required to spread a bunch of lies and fabrications so that the plans to attack Iran might come to fruition. U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney... requested that the media accuse Iran of any incident that might occur, even it be the work of the 'blue devil' [itself]. Cheney thus instructed [the U.S. media]: 'It is important that you sell [the message] that Iran and no one else is responsible for everything that may happen to us.' What a wonderful media this is!

"Is this logic different from the rationale behind the Nazi propaganda led by Joseph Goebbels, with its motto, 'Lie and lie again, and keep lying, until something sticks to the minds of the masses or until you, yourself, come to believe it!?'(3)  Are the U.S. media not portraying white as black and black as white, to comply with Vice President's Cheney's orders? Are we not facing here the exact Nazi propaganda formula – a leader issuing orders and the media making sure they are fulfilled, and falsifying [the truth] blindly and automatically?!!...

"Who said that the Americans are not reliable? A report published [in a neo-con paper] admitted that the [U.S.] media is required to accuse Iran of any action the U.S. may be subjected to – and this must be done immediately, without doubt or hesitation. The media is also required to hide any evidence that might implicate other elements involved in such action. Note the professionalism, reliability, neutrality and freedom of the press [enjoyed by the American media].

"What is the difference between this 'utterly free' U.S. media and the contemptible official Arab media used by the Arab governments as a propaganda mouthpiece to mislead, conceal, and promote ignorance among the masses for their disgraceful recruitment?

"Oh, Goebbels, how you have been wronged! They demonize you, scoff at your methods, make you into a symbol of lies, hypocrisy and communications failure – only to imitate your methods in minute detail. There is only one small difference: your [i.e. Goebbels's] media communications were primitive; they failed over fifty years ago – while they [the U.S.] have an unprecedented state-of-the-art communications empire..."

Endnotes:
(1) Al-Thawra (Syria), September 17, 2007.
(2) Labor Day is designated in the U.S. on the second Monday of each September.
(3) The quote appears at http://en.thinkexist.com/quotation/-if_you_tell_a_lie_big_enough_and_keep_repeating/345877.html as: "If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it."


*********************
The Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI) is an independent, non-profit organization that translates and analyzes the media of the Middle East. Copies of articles and documents cited, as well as background information, are available on request.

MEMRI holds copyrights on all translations. Materials may only be used with proper attribution.

The Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI)
P.O. Box 27837, Washington, DC 20038-7837
Search previous MEMRI publications at www.memri.org