IDF onderzoek spreekt beschuldigingen tegen over misdragingen Gaza Oorlog

Ook elders heb ik gelezen dat van zowel het voorval van de Palestijnse moeder met haar twee dochters die de verkeerde kant op gingen als van de oudere vrouw die doodgeschoten zou zijn eigenlijk hemelaal geen bewijzen zijn, en dit niet uit eerste hand is verteld. Uit onderzoek zou nu blijken dat zij helemaal niet zijn doodgeschoten.

 

Dat wil niet zeggen dat er geen onnodig geweld is gebruikt, maar het laat wel zien dat de media wel erg snel bovenop een verhaal springen over vermeende Israelische oorlogsmisdaden, en Israel wel erg makkelijk in de beklaagdenbank wordt gezet, zonder dat er nog enig bewijs is. Niet iedereen die wat negatiefs over Israel heeft te vertellen heeft gelijk, ook niet als het Joden of Israeli's betreft.

 

RP

---------------

 

Article is dated 22.3.09 from Maariv.
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
IDF Investigation Refutes the Testimonies About Gaza Killings
http://zionism-israel.com/israel_news/2009/03/idf-investigation-refutes-testimonies.html

Maariv in (Hebrew) - http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART1/869/248.html
22.3.09

[Complete translation by Israel News ] 

 

Today, Sunday, the conclusions of the personal investigation conducted by an IDF commander, whose troops fought in Gaza, following testimony of soldiers in his brigade about incidents of killing of Palestinian civilians during Operation Cast Lead. The investigation reveals that in at least two of the incidents mentioned in the testimony, which raised a storm of public controversy, no Palestinian women were killed as had been claimed.

Two central incidents that were brought to light in the testimony, which Danny Zamir, the head of the Rabin pre-military academy presented to Chief of Staff Gaby Ashkenazi, focus on one infantry brigade. Today the brigade's commander will present the findings of his personal investigation about the matter which he undertook in the last few day to Brigadier General Eyal Eisenberg, commander of the Gaza division,, and after approval, he will present his findings to the head of the Southern Command, Major General Yoav Gallant.

 

Light Finger on the trigger

 

Regarding the incident in which it was claimed that a sniper fired at a Palestinian woman and her two daughters, the brigade commander's investigation cites the sniper: "I saw the woman and her daughters and I shot warning shots. The section commander came up to the roof and shouted at me, 'Why did you shoot at them.' I explained that I did not shoot at them, but I fired warning shots."

 

Officers from the brigade suspect that fighters who remained in the lower story of the Palestinian house thought that he hit the the women, and from there the rumor that a sniper killed a mother and her two daughters spread.

 

Regarding the second incident, in which it was claimed that soldiers went up to the roof to entertain themselves with firing and killed an elderly Palestinian woman, the brigade commander investigation found that there was no such incident.

 

According to one of the officers, "The number of terrorists killed and the extent of arrests in "Operation Cast Lead" varied from brigade to brigade because the troops fought in different areas, and as part of the tradition there is always competition to show that your brigade is more combat ready. Nonetheless, the official evaluation  has not yet begun and among field commanders there is a fear that troops will bring to light additional incidents that took place during the fighting.

 

An officer of an elite unit that fought deep in Palestinian territory in Operation Cast Lead told NRG  Maariv, "There was a light trigger finger during operation Cast Lead without a doubt, and non-combatant ("uninvolved") civilians were killed without doubt. But there was no deliberate harm done to innocent civilians. I am fully convinced that there was no soldier who shot for no reason out of a desire for revenge. I don't know of any such cases.